|
Miralces,
Veda and Modern Science
by
Vishnu
Bhaskar
Executive
Summary: We
are passing through the Age of Spiritualism. This is reflected
from the international best sellers and award winning
publications. Most of these books have occult, spiritual message.
The world wide spread of the massage of Yoga further strengthens
the belief of the word in occult sciences. Modern science in their
attempt to explain the origin of the universe has stumbled upon
human consciousness as one of the important component of unified
theory to explain cosmic to cosmos. The modern age of
communication and mass media like TV have taken the isolated
unexplainable events to the home of the masses. Many of these
events appear miraculous and remains unexplained by conventional
Newtonian science. There is convergence of views appearing in the
horizon of frontiers of human knowledge. In this paper an attempt
has been made to put together the convergence of miracles, Veda
and modern science. It is hoped that readers see the reason behind
miracles in a more scientific way.
I
Background
1
Miracles are phenomena or events that cannot be explained
by conventional science; because miracles cannot be explained in
terms of science their existence is often challenged. Even when they
are seen in reality explanations for their occurrence are subject to
frequent debate and controversy. Since the rise of modern science
anti-supernatural arguments have stressed the principle of
uniformity. Scientists argue that:
-
Scientific
understanding is always based on constant repetition of events.
-
Miracles
are not constantly repeated.
-
Therefore,
there is no scientific way to understand miracles.
2
Two things
should be noted about this argument. First,
this form of the argument does not deny that unusual events like
miracles may occur. It simply says that scientific law is based on
regularities. And until one can establish a constant conjunction
between cause and effect there is no scientific basis for assuming a causal
connection between them.
3
Second, neither
does this argument deny that there is any scientific way to analyze
singularities, such as the
origin of the universe, or the
origin of life, or receiving one message
from outer space. It simply says that observed
regularities must be
the basis for analyzing singularities. For example, if
we observe over and over again that a certain kind of effect
regularly results from a certain kind of cause then when we discover
even a singular case of this kind of effect (whether from
the past or present), we have a scientific basis for assuming it had
the same kind of cause too. This same assumption is behind the
scientists' search for a chemical basis for the origins of life and an evolutionary
basis for the origin of species. In both cases repeatable
observations in the present are used as a basis for understanding
the singularity of origin in the past. Without this principle of
uniformity there would be no way of getting at singularities in
either the past or the present.
4
In brief, the
principle of repeatability that scientists use to attack miracles
actually boomerangs to support the miracles. Scientist is defeated
at its own game of science on its own principles.
II
Phenomena unexplained yet
widely accepted
1
If one already believes that there are facts, which are
impossible for science to explain, then one would be already
predisposed towards a belief in miracles. Such facts could be:
Ø
Religious experiences in people
Ø
Selfless love and sacrifice
Ø
Objective values (e.g., morality)
Ø
God and an afterlife
Ø
Free will
Ø
Mind or consciousness
Ø
Life
Ø
Basic uniformities of nature
Ø
The fact that the uniformities permit life
Ø
Laws of logic
Ø
Abstract entities, like numbers
Ø
The existence of the universe itself
Ø
The fact that something exists
2
It is argued above that when people work as scientists,
they necessarily have a scientific worldview. But do they, in
addition, necessarily believe that such a worldview is complete and
not contradicted by anything else in reality? There are indeed
scientists who do not regard the scientific worldview to be complete
in that way. In their scientific work, they are only methodological
scientists and not also metaphysical scientists. That is, they
assume laws of nature as an outlook presupposed by their scientific
work, but they do not regard naturalism to be generally true of all
reality. They might say, "I can make no reference to miracles
here in science, but science is limited; there are aspects of
reality that lie beyond it."
III
Miracles
and Modern Science
1
Traditional science
excludes miracles altogether. But quantum mechanics
and thermodynamics make miracles possible, the Multiverse
makes them likely, and the Anthropic Principle makes
it possible for us to actually observe them.
2
From Impossible to Improbable:
Classically speaking Law of Conservation of Energy states
impossibility of building a machine, which makes energy out of
nothing. The definition of a miracle in terms of impossibility
is useful, but times have changed. Ludwig Boltzmann
discovered that the so-called Second "Law" of
Thermodynamics is not a statement of prohibition – it is only a
statement of improbability. The flow of heat from a cooler body to a
hotter isn't impossible, it is just improbable. The
probability of it happening to a measurable extent is extremely
small, but nevertheless it is a positive number greater than zero
(the exact size of which depends on what the temperatures of the
"hotter" and "cooler" bodies are and how much
heat we want to flow between them).
3
Quantum mechanics takes
this a step further, because in the quantum world almost anything is
possible with some non-zero probability. For example, quantum
mechanics says that objects can penetrate (classically) impenetrable
barriers. You probably won't get through a brick wall just by
walking into it, but there is some extremely small but non-zero
probability that you will.
4
Since, in
practice, the notion of "impossibility" is a very useful
one, we have had to redefine the meaning of "impossible".
Where it used to mean a zero probability, now it means a very
small probability.
IV
The
Anthropic Principle
1
The critical
part of this Anthropic Principle is the statement that
"regardless of how improbable" an event is, the
improbability could be lower than any chosen bound for
"impossibility", which means that the Anthropic
Principle is telling us that, in certain circumstances, an
"impossible" event must have happened. Thus the
Anthropic Principle gives us a scientific theory of
"miracles".
2
An Example: One
of the biggest mysteries of biology is the origin of life. The combination of Darwin's theory of
evolution, the fossil record and modern genetics can tell us a lot
about the evolution of life from the earliest single-celled
organisms up to the appearance of human beings and other modern life
forms. But we remain profoundly ignorant about how the first
life form arose from non-living predecessors. What the Anthropic
Principle tells us is that if there is no way for life to form
without some miraculous event E, then, by the principle of
necessity, and the observation that we do exist, we can conclude
that miracle E did occur.
V
Multiverses
1
There are
really only two ways to get a large number of opportunities for
unlikely events to happen within a universe like our own:
-
The
universe is really, really large, or,
-
There
is a really, really large number of different
"parallel" universes, a so-called multiverse.
-
Either
or both of these options will work. As far as we know, there is
currently no known upper bound on the physical size of the
universe.
2
As for the
multiverse, it is not even possible in principle to place an upper
bound on the number of distinct "universes", once we admit
the possibility of there existing some universe other than our own.
If you prefer to actually know that there must exist multiple
universes, before you are prepared to believe that there might
exist multiple universes, then your best option is probably the
Many-Worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics. The Many-Worlds
interpretation asserts that the quantum wave-function doesn't
"collapse", and this non-collapse forces a
reinterpretation of classical approximations to quantum mechanics as
ever-splitting classical "universes". The number of
"splits" that you can get from the Many-Worlds
interpretation is more than enough to create a bacterium-sized
origin of life miracle.
VI
Spotting
Miraculous Evolution
1
One
of the supposed "fallacies" of evolution is the idea that
there is something special about the sequence of evolutionary steps
leading to our own existence. Evolution is the result of the natural
phenomena of mutation, recombination and natural selection acting on
our ancestors in the same way as on the ancestors of all other
living creatures. To think otherwise is to give ourselves an
unjustified special place in the scheme of things, as if we were the
very things for which the Universe had been constructed (for
example, by God).
2
It's all very
humbling to accept that we are not special; except that the
Anthropic Principle suggests that maybe we are still special.
If there are any miracles in the path of evolutionary development,
those miracles will only be observed on that part of the
evolutionary pathway, which leads directly to us. As the
reconstructions of genetic evolution become more detailed, it may
turn out to be possible to spot these miracles, or, at least, to
spot characteristics of evolution on the "main line" (i.e.
the line leading to us).
VII
Aliens
Explained
1
Until we find
hard evidence that some miracle has occurred in the origin and
evolution of life, it might seem that the Anthropic Principle is a
theory looking for something to explain. But there is one mystery
that it can help clear up, which is the mystery of the missing
aliens. We would expect that if an alien civilisation developed
to the stage of current human civilisation, then soon afterwards it
would expand into space and have a visible effect on its
surroundings, and one way or another we would be able to observe
this effect ourselves. But there is no visible sign of any life in
the universe other than our own, leading to speculation about what
"happened" to the aliens.
2
If the
development of intelligent life requires one or more miracles, then
we will never see the development of any intelligent life
independent of our own origins. Of course if there's a multiverse of
universes, then there will be aliens living in other universes, but
almost every intelligent species will be utterly alone in the
universe that it inhabits (and we must presume that there is no way
to travel between universes, otherwise we would be back to
having to explain why we can't see any aliens ourselves).
VIII
Miracles
and Parapsychology
1
In
the field of parapsychology we have a large number of classes of
mental and physical phenomena which are considered miracles. These
three classes are given below:
Ø
Mental
phenomena: often
described as extrasensory perception – phenomena aquired by means
other than five senses, this class includes unusual mental states or
abilities, such as:
¨
Telepathy
– thoughts, feelings & activities of other person
¨
Clairvoyance
– remote viewing
¨
Precognition
– Information about future place or events before they happen
Ø
Physical
phenomena:
this class includes unusual physical occurrences, such as:
¨
Psychokinesis
– remote
movement by mind
¨
Poltergeists
– spirits moving inanimate objects
¨
Stigmata
– marks,
sores or pains at locations of crucification wounds of Jesus
¨
Paranormal
vanishing
– disappearance of object or person before an audience
¨
Reality
shifts –
changes in physical (easy healing) or in spatial environment
¨
Materializations
– appearance of some material out of nothing
Ø
Survival
phenomena:
this class deals with the survival of consciousness after physical
death and includes:
¨
Ghosts
– spirits or apparition of a deceased person or his likeness
¨
Out-of-body
experiences (OBEs)
– sensation of floating outside one’s body and seeing oneself
from outside
¨
Reincarnation
– rebirth
¨
Near-death
experiences (NDEs)
– experiencing clinical death and then revivied (more common in
modern times specially with the development of cardiac resuscitation
techniques)
Ø
Other miraculous phemomena which scientists have been unable
to explain are:
¨
Alien
abduction experiences
- non-human creatures (usually aliens) kidnap individuals
¨
Cryptozoology
– animals rumoured to exist but no proof eg. Yeti, Sea-serpent,
mythological animals
¨
Deja
vu –
witnessing or experiencing new situation perviously
¨
Folie
a deux –
madness (other psychoses) shared by two individuals by transmission
from one to another
¨
Spontaneous
human combustion
– burning of a person’s body without external source of ignition
¨
UFOs
– Flying object’s that remain unidentified
2
To
be classified as a miracle, a phenomenon must lack a scientific
explanation. When an any such miracle receives a valid scientific
explanation, it becomes an accepted scientific truth. This has
happened in the past in many cases. For example, while the idea of
stones falling from the sky was once considered anomalous,
meteorites are now acknowledged and well understood. Another examle
is that of electromagnetic fields (EMF). At one time EMF was
debatable from a scientific perspective but later was proven to be
real and is currently accepted by scientific and medical
communitities.
IX
Veda,
Miracles and Modern Science
1
The Vedas describe an ultimate reality, which they call
Brahman. The awareness
of this reality is attained through the practice of yoga and
meditation. “Aham
Brahmasmi” (I am Brahman) is the statement of this realization and
identification, which is synonymous with the concept of nirvana.
Conceptions of Brahman and nirvana are integral to the
different schools of Indian and Buddhist Philosophy.
However until, recently, they had not been subject to
scientific scrutiny. Physicists have discovered that the various
quantum fields, which underline all physical reality, arise from one
common source, namely the unified field.
There is an over all connection between two primary
realities-the unified field and consciousness.
2
John Wheeler and Roger Penrose, the foremost theorists
about space and time believe that the mysteries of consciousness and
quantum physics are linked. Penrose
insists that a universe whose laws do not take consciousness into
account is not much of a universe.
The theory that consciousness emerged as a natural
consequence of the unique features of our universe has become a
topic of much scientific discussion. It is called the “Anthropic Cosmological Principle”.
3
In quantum physics consciousness could scarcely play a
more pivotal role. No
quantum phenomenon is a phenomenon until is observed in a
communicable form by a conscious observer.
For example, a photon exists both as a wave and as a
particle, but the individual property of a wave or a particle
becomes manifest only hen it is observed.
4
According to Vedic and Buddhist spiritual traditions,
consciousness is not something that comes about merely though the
functioning of neural connections in the brain but is a basic
characteristics of all reality, a spirit pervading all
manifestations. The
role of the human nervous system is to provide an appropriate
material structure to individualize consciousness.
In other words, we are the tuners of the all-pervading field
of cosmic awareness. The
discoveries of modern quantum physics seem, therefore, to parallel
Vedic and Buddhist conjectures about the nature of reality.
X
Conclusion
1
The current reality is something akin to what prevailed
in the Age of Alchemy when the then so-called Alchemists were
engrossed in their search for the ‘Philosopher's Stone’, the
substance which was believed to transform lesser metals into gold.
Though they never found the much sought after stone itself, their
quest promoted science in general. Ultimately leading to the
industrial revolution and modern science.
2
In our search for an explanation of consciousness we may
or may not be able to solve the riddle of reality, but our attempts
at solving this problem has lead, and will continue to lead, to
amazing discoveries about consciousness and related matters. And
with the passage of time many of the phenomena – mental or
physical classified at present as miracles will find scientific
explanations.
*******
|